Independent site. Data from NYC Open Data; not affiliated with the City of New York.

NYC Property Factsfree public-records reference

9 Commerce Street, Manhattan, NY 10014

BBL 1005870062 (Borough 1, Block 587, Lot 62) · BIN 1009970 · Last updated:

Summary · as of November 6, 2026

9 Commerce Street (Manhattan, NY 10014; tax lot BBL 1005870062) is a 3-unit walk-up apartment building (building class C0: three-family walk-up), built around 1826, on a 835 sq ft lot zoned C2-6. City tax records list the owner as SMITH, TAMI J; per ACRIS, a deed to this owner dated May 25, 2022 lists a price of $6,300,000. The Department of Finance's final market value for tax year 2027 is $6,422,000. As of November 6, 2026, NYC Open Data shows one DOB job with a permit issued but no sign-off. There was one 311 request in the past 12 months and no HPD complaints since 2019. (Source: NYC Open Data — DOB, HPD, OATH, DOF, DCP and ACRIS datasets — compiled by NYC Property Facts.)

Owner of record
SMITH, TAMI J
Building class
C0 · Three-family walk-up
Year built · units
1826 · 3 res.
Lot area · zoning
835 sq ft · C2-6
Market value (DOF)
$6,422,000 FY2027
Last priced deed
$6,300,000 · 2022-05-25
BBL
1005870062
BIN
1009970

How to cite: NYC Property Facts, “9 Commerce Street, Manhattan, NY 10014 (BBL 1005870062)”, data as of 2026-11-06, https://nycpropertyfacts.com/ny/manhattan/9-commerce-street-1005870062. Source: NYC Open Data.

Lot & building

Basic facts about the tax lot and building from the city’s PLUTO database.

Owner (as listed by the city)
SMITH, TAMI JThe owner name on the city’s tax records. It can lag behind recent sales and is often an LLC.
Building class
C0 – Three-family walk-upThe Department of Finance’s category for what kind of building this is.
Land use
Multi-family walk-up buildingsCity Planning’s broad category of how the lot is used.
Year built
1826Often an estimate for older buildings. Major alteration recorded: 2012.
Floors
3
Units
3 residential / 3 totalResidential units are apartments; total includes stores and offices.
Buildings on lot
1
Lot size
835 sq ft (19.58 ft × 40 ft)
Building floor area
2,584 sq ft
Zoning
C2-6The zoning district sets what can be built and used here. Commercial district.
Built vs. allowed density (FAR)
3.09 built / 3.44 max residentialFloor Area Ratio = building floor area ÷ lot area. If built FAR is below the maximum, zoning may allow more floor area (other rules apply).
Historic district
Greenwich Village Historic DistrictExterior changes in a historic district need Landmarks Preservation Commission approval.
Identifiers
BBL 1005870062 (Borough 1, Block 587, Lot 62) · BIN 1009970BBL identifies the tax lot; BIN identifies each building (from DOB/HPD/footprint records).

Source: PLUTO (Dept. of City Planning) — city dataset updated 2026-08-24; data as of 2026-11-06; Building Footprints — city dataset updated 2026-10-25; data as of 2026-11-01

Tax assessment

How the Department of Finance values this lot for property tax.

Market value (tax year 2027, final roll)
$6,422,000The Department of Finance’s estimate of value for tax purposes. It is not an appraisal and is often far from the sale price.
Assessed value
$385,320The portion of market value that taxes are calculated on (capped by law for small homes).
Taxable value (final)
$250,496Assessed value minus any exemptions.
Tax class
Tax class 1 – 1–3 family homes (and some small mixed-use / vacant lots)
Tax yearRollMarket valueAssessed valueTax class
2027Final$6,422,000$385,3201
2026Final$7,555,000$453,3001
2025Final$6,188,000$371,2801

Source: DOF Property Valuation and Assessment Data — city dataset updated 2026-09-14; data as of 2026-11-06

Sales & deed history 8

Deeds recorded with the City Register (ACRIS). A deed transfers ownership. A $0 or very low price usually means a transfer between related parties, an estate, or a refinance-related transfer, not a market sale. This is not a title search; mortgages, liens and other documents are not shown.

DateTypePriceSeller (grantor)Buyer (grantee)Doc ID
2022-05-25DEED$6,300,0009 Commerce Equities LlcThe Edward Sonnenschein, Jr. Trust Dated 6/25/20; Smith, Tami J; Edward Sonnenschein Jr. As Trustee2022053100803001
2015-03-27DEED$5,550,0009 Commerce Holding, Llc9 Commerce Equities Llc2015040300102001
2012-06-08DEED$2,650,0009 Commerce Street Realty Llc9 Commerce Holding Llc2012061300219001
2010-08-17DEED$2,475,0009 Commerce Street, Inc9 Commerce Street Realty Llc2010082400525001
2007-03-09DEED$2,150,000Rosenberg, Herbert9 Commerce Street, Inc.2007031900254002
1995-07-19DEED$0 / not statedRosenberg, Herbert; Patla, Donald L. DeceasedRosenberg, HerbertFT_1950004786595
1976-04-28DEED$0 / not statedWolpe, HildaPatla, Donald L; Rosenberg, HerbertFT_1370008560637
1973-05-03DEED$0 / not statedHanna, Ruth MWolpe, HildaFT_1750008520075

Source: ACRIS Real Property Master — city dataset updated 2026-10-08; data as of 2026-11-06; ACRIS Real Property Legals — city dataset updated 2026-10-08; data as of 2026-11-06; ACRIS Real Property Parties — city dataset updated 2026-10-08; data as of 2026-11-06

DOB job filings 1 open of 4

A “job” is an application to the Department of Buildings to do construction work. A job marked Permitted, not signed off had a work permit issued but the city has no record of final sign-off (inspection/completion). Old jobs left in this state are common and appear in buyer and lender due diligence; the work may or may not have been done.

StatusJob #TypeFiledEst. cost
Permitted, not signed off
PERMIT ISSUED - ENTIRE JOB/WORK · 2007-07-06
104824022
BIS
A2 – Alteration with multiple work types (no change to use/occupancy)2007-07-03$5,000
Not open
SIGNED OFF · 2015-01-23
122237793
BIS
A2 – Alteration with multiple work types (no change to use/occupancy)2014-12-23$3,000
Not open
SIGNED OFF · 2014-04-15
121638923
BIS
A3 – Minor alteration (one type of work)2013-06-03—
Not open
SIGNED OFF · 2015-02-19
121144993
BIS
A1 – Major alteration (changes use, egress or occupancy)2012-07-12$94,000

Source: DOB NOW: Build – Job Application Filings — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06; DOB Job Application Filings (BIS) — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06

Work permits 9

Individual permits issued under DOB jobs (one job can have several permits, e.g. plumbing and construction). Permit expiration alone does not mean the job was completed or signed off.

IssuedExpiresJob #WorkPermit status
2014-12-232015-12-23122237793
BIS
Plumbing / PlumbingISSUED (initial)
2014-09-112015-09-11121144993
BIS
Plumbing / PlumbingISSUED (renewal)
2013-08-062014-07-02121144993
BIS
AlterationISSUED (renewal)
2013-08-062014-07-02121144993
BIS
Construction equipment (scaffold, fence, shed) / Construction equipmentISSUED (renewal)
2013-06-032014-01-03121638923
BIS
Construction equipment (scaffold, fence, shed) / Construction equipmentISSUED (initial)
2013-03-072014-03-07121144993
BIS
Plumbing / PlumbingISSUED (initial)
2012-10-172013-08-02121144993
BIS
AlterationISSUED (initial)
2012-10-172013-08-02121144993
BIS
Construction equipment (scaffold, fence, shed) / Construction equipmentISSUED (initial)
2007-07-062007-08-30104824022
BIS
Equipment work / Other / general constructionISSUED (initial)

Source: DOB NOW: Build – Approved Permits — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06; DOB Permit Issuance (BIS) — city dataset updated 2026-10-31; data as of 2026-10-31

DOB violations 0 active of 3

Violations issued by the Department of Buildings for building-code or zoning conditions. Active means DOB has not recorded the violation as resolved or dismissed. Many active DOB violations are old (e.g. elevator or boiler inspection paperwork).

StatusIssuedTypeDescriptionNumber
Resolved/dismissed
V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED
2009-06-09LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEV*060909LANDMK09-1171
Resolved/dismissed
V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED
1992-08-03LANDMRK-LANDMARK NONEV*080392LANDMRKVIOL
Resolved/dismissed
V*-DOB VIOLATION - DISMISSED
1992-08-03LANDMK-LANDMARK NONEV*080392LANDMK93-0044

Source: DOB Violations — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06

ECB violations (DOB) 0 active of 4

DOB violations that go to a hearing at OATH (formerly the Environmental Control Board) and can carry fines. Active or Resolved follows the DOB violation status field. The hearing status is about the hearing and its penalty: written off means the city stopped collecting the fine, not that the condition was corrected. A balance due is a fine the city says is unpaid.

StatusIssuedSeverityWhat it was forPenalty / paid / balanceECB #
Resolved
Hearing: IN VIOLATION · Certification: CERTIFICATE ACCEPTED
2007-05-18Non-HazardousWORK W/O PERMIT. WORK NOTED: WORK IN PROGRESS AT 3 FLR. DEMOLITION OF WALLS CEILINGS (FIRE RATED) W/O FIRST OBTAINING APPROVALS & PERMITS BYTHE DEPT AS IS REQUIRED. WORK LOCATION 3 FL APT- WORK COMPLETED APPROX$500 / $548 / $034579653Y
Resolved
Hearing: IN VIOLATION · Certification: CERTIFICATE ACCEPTED
2013-05-14CLASS - 1FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS & PROPERTY AFFECTED BY CONSTRUCTION OPERATIONS. DEFECT NOTED: AT TIME OF INSPECTION THERE IS NO FALL PROTECTION INSTALLED AT WINDOW OPENINGS AT REAR OF BLDG. UNSAFE TEMPORARY$2,400 / $2,400 / $035015111M
Resolved
Hearing: IN VIOLATION · Certification: CERTIFICATE ACCEPTED
2013-05-14CLASS - 2FAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROVED/ACCEPTED PLANS AT JOB SITE AT TIME OF INSPECTION. DEFECT NOTED: AT TIME OF INSPECTION NO PLANS ARE AT SITE FOR JOB #121144993. STOP ALL WORK. MAKE SITE SAFE. REMEDY: PROVIDE PLANS.$250 / $250 / $035015108L
Resolved
Hearing: IN VIOLATION · Certification: CERTIFICATE ACCEPTED
2013-05-14CLASS - 2SEC. 1704.1.1 FAILURE TO FILE A SPECIAL INSPECTION STATEMENT OF RESPONSIBILITY PRIOR TO PERMIT ISSUANCE & PRIOR TO START OF WORK UNDER SPECIAL INSPECTION REQUIREMENT. DEFECT NOTED: AT TIME OF INSPECTION NO TR1$400 / $400 / $035015109N

Source: DOB ECB Violations — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06

OATH tickets (all agencies) 0 unpaid of 20

Summonses heard at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, from agencies like Sanitation, Buildings, Fire and Health, linked to this lot’s block and lot. Default means the respondent did not appear at the hearing, which typically results in the maximum penalty. Tickets may be issued to tenants or businesses at the address, not just the owner. DOB ECB tickets appear here too.

StatusDateAgencyChargeRespondentImposed / paid / balanceTicket #
No balance due
HEARING COMPLETED · IN VIOLATION
2022-07-13Dos - Enforcement AgentsSTORAGE OF RECEPTACLES 1ST OCCURRENCESMITH TAMI J$50 / $50 / $0047422555R
No balance due
HEARING COMPLETED · DISMISSED
2020-05-04Sanitation OthersSTORAGE OF RECEPTACLES9 COMMERCE EQUITIES LLC$0 / $0 / $00210847203
No balance due
WRITTEN OFF · WRITTEN OFF
2015-01-06Dep - Bureau Of Cust. ServiceMETER REPAIR REMOVAL WITHOUT A PERMIT.9 COMMERCE HOLDING LLC$500 / $0 / $00181791996
No balance due Default
PAID IN FULL · DEFAULT
2014-10-03Dept Of TranFAILURE TO PERMANENTLY RESTORE CUT WITHIN REQUIRED TIMECON EDISON$830 / $800 / —0187309522
No balance due
APPEAL DECIS RENDERD · IN VIOLATION
2013-05-14Dept. Of BuildingsFAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS AND PROP AFFECTED BY CONST OPERATIONSANDY BASSALY C O TR1-BASSCO,$2,400 / $2,400 / —035015111M
No balance due
PAID IN FULL · IN VIOLATION
2013-05-14Dept. Of BuildingsFAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROVED ACCEPTED PLANS AT JOB SITE AT TIME OF INSP9 COMMERCE HOLDING LLC$250 / $250 / —035015108L
No balance due
PAID IN FULL · IN VIOLATION
2013-05-14Dept. Of BuildingsMISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONS9 COMMERCE HOLDING LLC$400 / $400 / —035015109N
No balance due Default
PAID IN FULL · DEFAULT
2012-10-11Sanitation DeptDIRTY AREA9 COMMERCE HOLDING LLC$300 / $103 / —043661932X
No balance due
HEARING COMPLETED · DISMISSED
2012-06-09Sanitation DeptDIRTY AREA9 COMMERCE STREET REALTY LLC— / — / —043502101R
No balance due
WRITTEN OFF · WRITTEN OFF
2012-06-04Dos - Enforcement AgentsDIRTY AREA9 COMMERCE STREET REALTY LLC$300 / $0 / $0043661251K
No balance due
WRITTEN OFF · WRITTEN OFF
2012-04-24Dos - Enforcement AgentsDIRTY AREA9 COMMERCE STREET REALTY LLC$300 / $0 / $0043580811P
No balance due
WRITTEN OFF · WRITTEN OFF
2012-04-14Dos - Enforcement AgentsDIRTY SIDEWALK DIRTY AREA9 COMMERCE STREET REALTY LLC$300 / $0 / $0043660958J

Showing 12 of 20 records. The API and the source dataset have the full list.

Source: OATH Hearings Division Case Status — city dataset updated 2026-11-06; data as of 2026-11-06

HPD registration & contacts

Owners of most rental buildings must register with the Department of Housing Preservation and Development each year and list an owner and managing agent.

No HPD registration found. Registration is required for buildings with 3 or more apartments (and for 1–2 family homes where neither the owner nor family lives there).

Source: HPD Multiple Dwelling Registrations — city dataset updated 2026-11-04; data as of 2026-11-06; HPD Registration Contacts — city dataset updated 2026-11-04; data as of 2026-11-06

HPD housing-code violations 0 open of 0

Violations HPD inspectors issued for conditions in residential buildings (heat, leaks, mold, pests, lead paint, etc.). Class letters show how serious: Class A – non-hazardous (HPD gives 90 days to correct); Class B – hazardous (30 days to correct); Class C – immediately hazardous (24 hours to correct for most conditions); Class I – information / order (e.g. orders to register, lead or other administrative orders). Open means HPD has not recorded the condition as corrected.

No records found in this dataset for this lot.

Source: HPD Housing Maintenance Code Violations — city dataset updated 2026-11-05; data as of 2026-11-06

HPD complaints 0

Complaints tenants or others made to HPD (usually via 311) about housing conditions, from 2019 onward. A complaint is not a violation; HPD may inspect and issue one.

No records found in this dataset for this lot.

Source: HPD Housing Maintenance Code Complaints and Problems — city dataset updated 2026-11-06; data as of 2026-11-06

311 requests (last 12 months) 1

Recent 311 service requests the city geocoded to this lot: noise, illegal parking, heat, sanitation and more. Anyone can file them, so they describe activity at or near the address, not necessarily the building itself.

OpenedAgencyComplaintStatusClosed
2026-01-13DOTStreet Sign - Damaged – Other/UnknownClosed2026-01-17

Source: 311 Service Requests from 2020 to Present — city dataset updated 2026-11-06; data as of 2026-11-06

Nearby properties

More in West Village: Open HPD violations · Active DOB violations · Active ECB violations · Open DOB jobs · Unpaid OATH tickets

On Commerce St

Same tax block (587)

All properties on Commerce St, Manhattan · All of Manhattan 10014

Open-item counts as of November 6, 2026; each section lists its own dataset date. Machine-readable: JSON API · Markdown · Plain text · API & MCP docs