# 9 Menahan Street, Brooklyn, NY 11221

BBL 3033040024 · Block 3304 · Lot 24 · BIN 3325703, 3340305  
Canonical page: https://nycpropertyfacts.com/ny/brooklyn/9-menahan-street-3033040024  
Last updated: 2026-10-31 · Open-item counts as of 2026-10-31

Also recorded as: 11 Menahan St; 11a Menahan St

## Summary

9 Menahan Street (Brooklyn, NY 11221; tax lot BBL 3033040024) is a 10-unit walk-up apartment building (building class C1: walk-up apartments, more than six families, no stores), built around 1930, on a 2,500 sq ft lot zoned R6. City tax records list the owner as MENAHAN PLAZA 1 LLC; per ACRIS, a deed to this owner dated September 28, 2022 lists a price of $1,350,000. The Department of Finance's final market value for tax year 2027 is $562,000. As of October 31, 2026, NYC Open Data shows 10 DOB jobs with a permit issued but no sign-off, one active DOB violation, one active ECB violation and two open HPD violations. There were 12 311 requests in the past 12 months and one HPD complaint since 2019. (Source: NYC Open Data — DOB, HPD, OATH, DOF, DCP and ACRIS datasets — compiled by NYC Property Facts.)

How to cite: NYC Property Facts, “9 Menahan Street, Brooklyn, NY 11221 (BBL 3033040024)”, data as of 2026-10-31, https://nycpropertyfacts.com/ny/brooklyn/9-menahan-street-3033040024. Source: NYC Open Data.

## Open items

| Item | Count |
|---|---|
| Open DOB jobs (permit issued, not signed off) | 10 |
| Active DOB violations | 1 |
| Active ECB violations | 1 |
| Open HPD violations | 2 |
| OATH tickets with unpaid balance | 0 |

## Lot & building

- Owner of record: MENAHAN PLAZA 1 LLC
- Building class: C1 – Walk-up apartments, more than six families, no stores
- Year built: 1930
- Floors: 4
- Units: 10 residential / 10 total
- Lot area: 2,500 sq ft · Building area: 8,938 sq ft
- Zoning: R6
- Source: PLUTO (Dept. of City Planning) (https://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/64uk-42ks), data as of 2026-10-31

## Tax assessment

- Tax year 2027 (final roll): market value $562,000, assessed value $252,900, tax class 2B
- Source: DOF Property Valuation and Assessment Data (https://data.cityofnewyork.us/d/8y4t-faws)

## Sales & deeds (ACRIS)

Deeds recorded with the City Register. amount 0 usually means a non-market transfer. lots_in_deed > 1 means the price covers several lots.

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022-09-28 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2022-09-28 from FINKELSTEIN, YORAM to MENAHAN PLAZA 1 LLC, stated price $1,350,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2017-09-14 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2017-09-14 from 9 MENAHAN ST. LLC to FINKELSTEIN, YORAM, stated price $1,100,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2013-12-12 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2013-12-12 from GRS 12 LLC to 9 MENAHAN ST. LLC, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2013-05-23 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2013-05-23 from GRAY, DARLENE to GRS12 LLC, stated price $190,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2006-11-02 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2006-11-02 from NRG DEVELOPMENT GROUP INC to GRAY, DARLENE, stated price $599,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2006-02-28 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2006-02-28 from MTGLQ INVESTORS L.P.; M.D. WEBB & ASSOCIATES INC. to NRG DEVELOPMENT GROUP INC., stated price $329,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2005-12-01 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2005-12-01 from KIMMEL, ESQ., REFEREE, LEO J to MTGLQ INVESTORS, L.P., stated price $400,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2003-02-28 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2003-02-28 from MARTINEZ, ANTONIO to RODRIGUEZ, RUBEN, stated price $330,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2003-02-28 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2003-02-28 from JACOB MOVTADY MONEY PURCHASE PENSION FUND to MARTINEZ, ANTONIO, stated price $220,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 2002-11-01 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 2002-11-01 from CHIDEKEL, REFEREE, DAVID M ESQ. to JACOB MOVTADY MONEY PURCHASE PENSION PLAN, stated price $220,000. | bnx9-e6tj |
| 1997-05-19 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 1997-05-19 from E.H. DEVELOPMENT CORP to BROWN, TYRONE, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |
| 1997-05-07 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 1997-05-07 from ROOSEVELT SAVINGS BANK/DEF; NYC PARKING VIOLATIONS BUREAU/DEF; WILLIAMS, JANE/DEF; MERCER, S HAL/REF; WILLIAMS, ELAINE/DEF; NYC ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL BOARD/DEF; PEOPLE OF THE STATEOF NEW YORK/DEF to EH DEVELOPMENT CORP, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |
| 1987-10-22 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 1987-10-22 from MORGAN,EDWARD WILLIAM/AK; MORGAN, EDWARD W to WILLIAMS, ELAINE, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |
| 1979-10-25 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 1979-10-25 from SECY OF HOUSING & URBAN DVLPT to MORGAN EDWARD W, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |
| 1978-10-25 | recorded (DEED) | DEED dated 1978-10-25 from FEDL NATL MTGE ASSN to SECY OF HOUSING & URBAN DVLPT, no price stated ($0). | bnx9-e6tj |

Showing 15 of 21. Full list: https://nycpropertyfacts.com/api/v1/property/3033040024/sales

## Open DOB jobs and recent work permits

A DOB "job" is an application to do construction work. status "open" = a permit was issued but DOB has no record of final sign-off. Work permits are listed with type "work_permit" and their DOB permit status (they are not counted as open items).

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-06-09 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B01413337-I1 (Alteration): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2025-07-14 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B01252711-I1 (Alteration): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2025-06-23 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00736930-S1 (ALT-CO - New Building with Existing Elements to Remain): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2025-03-28 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00736930-S5 (ALT-CO - New Building with Existing Elements to Remain): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2023-03-20 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00736930-S6 (ALT-CO - New Building with Existing Elements to Remain): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2023-03-16 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00834550-I1 (Alteration): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2022-10-06 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00736930-S4 (ALT-CO - New Building with Existing Elements to Remain): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2022-05-27 | open (Permit Entire) | DOB NOW job filing B00736930-I1 (ALT-CO - New Building with Existing Elements to Remain): Permit Entire — permit issued, no sign-off on record. | w9ak-ipjd |
| 2025-02-27 | open (PERMIT ISSUED - ENTIRE JOB/WORK) | BIS job 340916398 (A3 – Minor alteration (one type of work)): PERMIT ISSUED - ENTIRE JOB/WORK — permit issued, no sign-off on record. HEREBY FILING FOR BPP FRONTAGE 25' ALTERATION TYPE 3 ASSOCIATED WITH JOB# B00736930. | ic3t-wcy2 |
| 2002-09-19 | open (PERMIT ISSUED - ENTIRE JOB/WORK) | BIS job 301413762 (A1 – Major alteration (changes use, egress or occupancy)): PERMIT ISSUED - ENTIRE JOB/WORK — permit issued, no sign-off on record. Change metes & bounds, No construction w ork done on this application. N in use, egrress, & occupancy. | ic3t-wcy2 |
| 2026-10-13 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B01252711-I1: Sidewalk Shed — INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AND PIPE SCAFFOLDING. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION, ALL WORK TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33…. Issued 2026-10-13, expires 2026-12-22. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-10-13 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B01252711-I1: Supported Scaffold — INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AND PIPE SCAFFOLDING. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION, ALL WORK TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33…. Issued 2026-10-13, expires 2026-12-22. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-10-09 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B01252711-I1: Supported Scaffold — INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AND PIPE SCAFFOLDING. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION, ALL WORK TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33…. Issued 2026-10-09, expires 2026-12-22. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-10-09 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B01252711-I1: Sidewalk Shed — INSTALLATION OF HEAVY DUTY SIDEWALK SHED AND PIPE SCAFFOLDING. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY OR EGRESS UNDER THIS APPLICATION, ALL WORK TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 33…. Issued 2026-10-09, expires 2026-12-22. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-07-20 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B00736930-S6: Structural — ST APPLICATION HEREBY FILED AS A SUBSEQUENT FILING TO JOB #B00736930.. Issued 2026-07-20, expires 2027-01-20. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-06-09 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B01413337-I1: Supported Scaffold — PROPOSED INSTALLATION OF TEMPORARY PIPE SCAFFOLD AS PER PLANS. WORK SHALL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER #33 OF 2022 THE NYC BUILDING CODE. NO CHANGE IN USE, OCCUPANCY, O…. Issued 2026-06-09, expires 2026-12-22. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-05-21 | n/a (Signed-off) | DOB NOW work permit for job B87321723-S1: Sprinklers — PIPING WITH STEEL SLEEVE THROUGH FOUNDATION WALL.. Issued 2026-05-21, expires 2026-08-05. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-05-21 | n/a (Signed-off) | DOB NOW work permit for job B87321723-S1: Plumbing — PIPING WITH STEEL SLEEVE THROUGH FOUNDATION WALL.. Issued 2026-05-21, expires 2026-08-05. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-02-23 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B00736930-I1: General Construction — PROPOSED ALTERATION TYPE 1 TO EXISTING 2 STORY + CELLAR BUILDING. VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL ENLARGEMENT. PROPOSED 4-STORY+CELLAR+MEZZ RESIDENTIAL USE BUILDING.. Issued 2026-02-23, expires 2027-01-20. | rbx6-tga4 |
| 2026-02-23 | n/a (Permit Issued) | DOB NOW work permit for job B00834550-I1: Construction Fence — HEREBY FILING FENCE APPLICATION IN CONJUNCTION TO JOB #B00736930-I1. Issued 2026-02-23, expires 2027-01-20. | rbx6-tga4 |

Showing 20 of 48. Full list: https://nycpropertyfacts.com/api/v1/property/3033040024/permits

## Open violations (DOB, ECB, HPD)

status "open" = DOB violation category is ACTIVE, ECB violation status is ACTIVE, or HPD violation status is Open.

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1993-08-16 | open (V-DOB VIOLATION - ACTIVE) | DOB violation (LL6291-LOCAL LAW 62/91 - BOILERS BOILER REQUIRED). Active — not recorded as resolved or dismissed. | 3h2n-5cm9 |
| 2026-02-19 | open (PENDING) | ECB (DOB) violation, class - 1: AT TIME OF INSPECTION OBSERVED: COLD FORM STEEL FRAMEWORK COMPLETED AT BULKHEAD LEVEL CORNER EXPOSURE# 2-3 WITHIN 66 FEET HEIGHT APPROX. CONTRARY TO PARTIAL STOP WORK ORDER ISSUED ON 12/23/2025, CREATING UNSAFE. Active. Balance due $10,000. | 6bgk-3dad |
| 2016-12-14 | open (Info Nov Sent Out) | HPD class I violation (Class I): § 27-2142 ADM CODE - THE PREMISES OR APTS. HAVE BEEN VACATED BY THE DEPARTMENT AND CANNOT BE REOCCUPIED UNTIL SO ORDERED AFTER PROOF OF COMPLIANCE FOR CELLAR APARTMENT AT WEST VACATE POSTING # 134654 LOCATED AT CELLAR APT. Open — not recorded as corrected. | wvxf-dwi5 |
| 2016-12-05 | open (Nov Sent Out) | HPD class B violation (Class B): § 27-2087 ADM CODE - DISCONTINUE USE OF ROOMS FOR LIVING, DISCONNECT PLUMBING FIXTURES WHERE ILLEGAL AND PROPERLY SEAL PIPE CONNECTIONS SLEPPING AREA CREATED AT CELLAR. Open — not recorded as corrected. | wvxf-dwi5 |

## OATH tickets with unpaid balance or pending

status "open" = balance due > $0 after a decision (cases awaiting a hearing are "pending"). default=true means the respondent did not appear.

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-03-20 | pending (RESCHEDULED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: FAIL TO COMPLY W COMMISSIONER ORDER TO FILE CERT OF CORRECTION W DOB. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2026-03-12 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: FAILED TO PROTECT ADJ. PROPERTY. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2026-03-12 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: FAILURE TO INSTITUTE MAINTAIN SAFETY EQUIPMENT ETC.,- NO GUARD RAILS. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2026-03-12 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONS. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2026-02-19 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: UNLAWFULLY CONTINUED WORK WHILE ON NOTICE OF A STOP WORK ORDER. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2026-01-23 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: WORK DOES NOT CONFORM TO APPROVED CONST. DOCUMENTS AND OR APPROVED AME. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |
| 2025-07-08 | pending (RESCHEDULED · ADJOURNED) | OATH ticket from Dept. Of Buildings: FAILED TO PROTECT ADJ. PROPERTY. Hearing pending. | jz4z-kudi |

## Complaints (HPD since 2019, 311 last 12 months)

Complaints are reports, not violations. status mirrors the published complaint / request status.

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021-10-18 | closed (CLOSE) | HPD complaint (apt 3R): Heat/Hot Water – Apartment Only. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development was not able to gain access to your apartment or others in the building to inspect for a lack of heat or hot water. The complaint has been close… | ygpa-z7cr |
| 2026-10-06 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOT: Street Condition – Blocked - Construction. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-09-27 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to NYPD: Blocked Driveway – No Access. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-08-24 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DEP: Air Quality – Asbestos Disturbance. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-08-07 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DEP: Air Quality – Asbestos Disturbance. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-07-05 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to NYPD: Noise - Street/Sidewalk – Loud Talking. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-02-02 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Site Conditions Endangering Workers. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-01-22 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Cons - Contrary/Beyond Approved Plans/Permits. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-01-19 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Adjacent Buildings Not Protected. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2026-01-06 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Adjacent Buildings Not Protected. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2025-12-30 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Working Contrary To Stop Work Order. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2025-12-23 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Sidewalk Shed/Pipe Scafford - Inadequate Defective/None. | erm2-nwe9 |
| 2025-12-22 | closed (Closed) | 311 request to DOB: General Construction/Plumbing – Sidewalk Shed/Pipe Scafford - Inadequate Defective/None. | erm2-nwe9 |

## Owners & contacts

Owner of record comes from city tax records (PLUTO) and can lag behind recent sales.

| Date | Status | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-24 | current | City tax records (PLUTO) list the owner as MENAHAN PLAZA 1 LLC. | 64uk-42ks |
| 2022-09-28 | recorded | Grantee (buyer) on the most recent deed (DEED, 2022-09-28). | 636b-3b5g |
| 2025-07-11 | expired_registration | HPD registration contact: HeadOfficer Yitzchok Kohn, business city Brooklyn. | feu5-w2e2 |
| 2025-07-11 | expired_registration | HPD registration contact: CorporateOwner (MENHAHAN PLAZA 1 LLC), business city Brooklyn. | feu5-w2e2 |
| 2025-07-11 | expired_registration | HPD registration contact: Agent Joel Stauber, business city Brooklyn. | feu5-w2e2 |

---

Independent site. Data from NYC Open Data; not affiliated with the City of New York. Not a title search or official record; verify with the issuing agency. JSON: https://nycpropertyfacts.com/api/v1/property/3033040024